Proctor Compaction Test — Optimum Water Content and Maximum Dry Density Worked Example
The compaction test looks simple, but two common mistakes ruin it: reading the highest test point as the optimum, and never checking the data against the zero-air-voids curve. This guide reduces one complete Proctor data set by hand, so you can check any spreadsheet or program against it. It covers the fitted curve, the optimum water content, the maximum dry unit weight, the checks that catch bad data, a field compaction check and the oversize correction.
1. The data
- Standard Proctor (ASTM D698), mold volume V = 944 cm³, mold mass 4200 g
- Specific gravity of the soil solids Gs = 2.70
- Six compaction points, water contents from about 9% to 19% on both sides of the optimum
For each point: wet density ρ = (mass of mold + wet soil − mold mass)/V; water content w = (wet soil + can − dry soil + can)/(dry soil + can − can) × 100; dry density ρd = ρ/(1 + w); dry unit weight γd = ρd × 9.81.
| Point | ρ wet (g/cm³) | w (%) | ρd (g/cm³) | γd (kN/m³) | γd,ZAV (kN/m³) | S (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.901 | 9.0 | 1.744 | 17.11 | 21.31 | 44 |
| 2 | 1.968 | 11.0 | 1.773 | 17.39 | 20.42 | 57 |
| 3 | 2.028 | 13.0 | 1.794 | 17.60 | 19.61 | 70 |
| 4 | 2.069 | 15.0 | 1.799 | 17.65 | 18.85 | 81 |
| 5 | 2.101 | 17.0 | 1.795 | 17.61 | 18.15 | 91 |
| 6 | 2.109 | 19.0 | 1.772 | 17.39 | 17.51 | 98 |
The zero-air-voids value is γd,ZAV = Gs·γw/(1 + w·Gs), and the degree of saturation of each point is S = w·Gs/(Gs·γw/γd − 1).
2. Fit the curve, do not pick the highest point
The highest test point is point 4 (γd = 17.65 kN/m³ at w = 15%). The true peak lies between points, so we fit a least-squares parabola through all six points, γd = a·w² + b·w + c:
- a = -0.01566, b = 0.4680, c = 14.160, with R² = 0.9944
- Optimum water content: wopt = −b/(2a) = 14.9%
- Maximum dry unit weight: γd,max = c − b²/(4a) = 17.66 kN/m³ (ρd,max = 1.800 g/cm³)
3. Checks that catch bad data
- No point above the zero-air-voids curve. The curve is a theoretical limit at S = 100%. The highest saturation here is 98% (point 6), so every point plots below it. A point above the curve means a wrong Gs, water content or weighing.
- The optimum lies inside the tested range. 14.9% is between 9% and 19%. If the fit peaks outside the data, add points; do not trust an extrapolated peak.
- R² close to 1. 0.994 here. A low R² usually means scatter or too few points on one side.
- Saturation at the optimum. S = 81% at wopt, a plausible value for a clayey or silty soil compacted at the optimum.
4. The water-content range for 95% compaction
Setting γd = 0.95 × 17.66 = 16.77 kN/m³ in the parabola gives two water contents, 7.4% on the dry side and 22.5% on the wet side. Look at them before using them: both lie outside the tested range of 9% to 19%, so they are extrapolations of a parabola. A parabola is only an approximation of the real curve, which usually falls faster on the wet side. In this example the fitted parabola crosses the zero-air-voids curve at w ≈ 19.6%, just beyond the last test point; above that value it would plot over the S = 100% limit, which is physically impossible. The wet-side limit of 22.5% is therefore not usable. Use such a range as an indication, and test points closer to the limits if the project depends on them.
5. Field check: relative compaction
Relative compaction is RC = ρd,field/ρd,max × 100. Suppose a field test (sand cone, for example) gives an assumed wet density of 1.95 g/cm³ at w = 12.5%. Then ρd,field = 1.95/1.125 = 1.733 g/cm³ and RC = 1.733/1.800 = 96.3%. The minimum RC and the allowed water-content band come from the project specification, not from this article; values such as 95% or 98% are common, but they are not universal.
6. Oversize correction (ASTM D4718)
When the soil contains a fraction Pc retained on the sieve that the mold does not allow, the laboratory result must be corrected. As an illustration, take Pc = 10%, Gs of the oversize 2.65 and its water content 2%:
- γd,corr = 1/[(1 − Pc)/γd,max + Pc/(Gs,os·γw)] = 18.24 kN/m³
- wcorr = (1 − Pc)·wopt + Pc·wos = 13.65%
Comparing field density with the uncorrected laboratory value would understate or overstate RC for such a soil.
7. Reproduce it in a spreadsheet
Enter method = Standard (ASTM D698), V = 944, mold mass = 4200, Gs = 2.70, oversize Pc = 0, and for the six points the data of the table (mold + wet soil: 5995, 6058, 6114, 6153, 6183, 6191 g; wet soil + can: 63.6, 64.4, 65.2, 66.0, 66.8, 67.6 g; dry soil + can: 60 g; can: 20 g for every point). You should get wopt = 14.9%, γd,max = 17.66 kN/m³ and R² = 0.994.
8. Limits of this example
- Dry-side and wet-side points matter equally: use at least two on each side of the optimum.
- The data here are synthetic and for teaching. The sheet performs data reduction only; the test itself must follow the standard (ASTM D698 or D1557).
- Do not reuse the same soil for every point after wetting it. Prepare each point from fresh soil or give it a proper curing time.
- The field requirements, RC and water-content limits belong to the engineer of record and the project specification.
Our Proctor Compaction Excel sheet does this data reduction with live formulas: six compaction points, a least-squares fit with wopt, γd,max and R², zero-air-voids and S = 90% curves, the water-content range for 95% compaction, the ASTM D4718 oversize correction, quality checks and a printable A4 report. Use the worked example above to test any sheet or program: same inputs, same answer.
Related worked examples
- Atterberg Limits Chart and USCS Classification — Four Worked Examples (CL, CH, ML, SC)
- Slope Stability by the Simplified Bishop Method — Worked Example
This article is an educational summary for preliminary checks. Compaction requirements must follow the project specification and the judgement of the engineer in charge.
Proctor Compaction Test Analysis Excel Sheet — Optimum Water Content, γd,max and Zero-Air-Voids — Bilingual
Full compaction data reduction with live formulas: wet and dry densities of 6 points, fitted compaction curve, optimum water content and max…
More guides
Foundation Settlement Worked Example — Immediate and Consolidation Settlement
Bearing Capacity of a Square Footing — Terzaghi vs Meyerhof Worked Example
Slope Stability by the Simplified Bishop Method — Worked Example
Atterberg Limits Chart and USCS Classification — Four Worked Examples (CL, CH, ML, SC)
CPT-Based Liquefaction Triggering: The Simplified Method Step by Step, with a Worked Example