Bearing Capacity of a Square Footing — Terzaghi vs Meyerhof Worked Example
Bearing-capacity formulas are easy to quote and easy to misapply. This guide works one complete example by hand: a square footing on a soil that has both cohesion and friction, with the Meyerhof and Terzaghi methods side by side and the water table in two positions. Every number can be reproduced in a spreadsheet, so you can check any tool you use against it.
1. The problem
- Square footing B = L = 2.0 m, embedment Df = 1.5 m, centric vertical load
- Soil: c′ = 10 kPa, φ′ = 30°, unit weight γ = 18 kN/m³ above the water table and γsat = 20 kN/m³ below it (effective-stress parameters, general shear failure)
- Case A: water table far below the footing. Case B: water table at the base of the footing
- Required factor of safety FS = 3
The overburden at the base is q = γ·Df = 18 × 1.5 = 27 kPa. It is the same in both cases, because the soil above the base is above the water table.
2. Meyerhof method
The general equation is qu = c·Nc·sc·dc + q·Nq·sq·dq + 0.5·γ·B·Nγ·sγ·dγ. For φ′ = 30°:
- Kp = tan²(45° + φ′/2) = 3.000
- Nq = eπ·tanφ′·Kp = 18.40
- Nc = (Nq − 1)/tanφ′ = 30.14
- Nγ = (Nq − 1)·tan(1.4φ′) = 15.67
Shape and depth factors (square footing, B/L = 1, φ′ > 10°):
- sc = 1 + 0.2·Kp·B/L = 1.600; sq = sγ = 1 + 0.1·Kp·B/L = 1.300
- dc = 1 + 0.2·√Kp·Df/B = 1.260; dq = dγ = 1 + 0.1·√Kp·Df/B = 1.130
Case A, water table far below. The three terms are:
- Cohesion: 10 × 30.14 × 1.600 × 1.260 = 608 kPa
- Surcharge: 27 × 18.40 × 1.300 × 1.130 = 730 kPa
- Self-weight: 0.5 × 18 × 2.0 × 15.67 × 1.300 × 1.130 = 414 kPa
So qu ≈ 1752 kPa and qall = qu/FS ≈ 584 kPa.
Case B, water table at the base. Only the self-weight term changes, because the soil below the base is now submerged: γ′ = γsat − 9.81 = 10.19 kN/m³. The term becomes 0.5 × 10.19 × 2.0 × 15.67 × 1.300 × 1.130 = 235 kPa, so qu ≈ 1572 kPa and qall ≈ 524 kPa.
3. Terzaghi method
For a square footing Terzaghi's equation is qu = 1.3·c·Nc + q·Nq + 0.4·γ·B·Nγ, with no depth factors: the soil above the base is treated only as a surcharge. For φ′ = 30°:
- Nq = e2(3π/4 − φ′/2)·tanφ′ / (2·cos²(45° + φ′/2)) = 22.46
- Nc = (Nq − 1)/tanφ′ = 37.16
- Nγ = 19.7 (Terzaghi's tabulated value; published tables differ slightly, for example 19.1, which changes the result by less than 1%)
Case A: 1.3 × 10 × 37.16 + 27 × 22.46 + 0.4 × 18 × 2.0 × 19.7 = 483 + 606 + 284 ≈ 1373 kPa, so qall ≈ 458 kPa.
Case B: replace γ by γ′ = 10.19 kN/m³ in the last term: 483 + 606 + 161 ≈ 1250 kPa, so qall ≈ 417 kPa.
4. Results side by side
| Method | qu, water far below (kPa) | qall, FS = 3 (kPa) | qu, water at base (kPa) | qall, FS = 3 (kPa) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meyerhof (with shape and depth factors) | 1752 | 584 | 1572 | 524 |
| Terzaghi (square footing) | 1373 | 458 | 1250 | 417 |
- The two methods differ by about 28%. Meyerhof gives the higher value here because its shape and depth factors are larger and Terzaghi has no depth factor. Both are accepted methods; the gap is a reminder that bearing capacity is an estimate, not an exact number.
- The water table costs about 9–10% in this example, not 50%. Only the self-weight term sees γ′, and that term is about 24% of qu here because the footing is embedded and the soil has cohesion. For a shallow footing on clean sand the self-weight term dominates and the loss is much larger. If the water table rises above the base, q also drops and the loss grows.
5. Check against the applied load
Suppose the column load, including the footing weight, is Q = 1500 kN. The applied pressure is Q/(B·L) = 1500/4 = 375 kPa. The actual factor of safety is qu/qapplied:
- Meyerhof: 1752/375 = 4.67 (water far below) and 1572/375 = 4.19 (water at base)
- Terzaghi: 1373/375 = 3.66 and 1250/375 = 3.33
The lowest value, 3.33, is above the required 3, so the footing passes in every combination. If a project reported only the most favourable value, it would hide how close the margin is in the worst case.
6. Reproduce it in a spreadsheet
Enter shape = Square, B = 2.0, Df = 1.5, c = 10, φ = 30, γ = 18, γsat = 20, FS = 3 and Q = 1500. Use a water-table depth of 99 m for case A and 1.5 m for case B. For Meyerhof, switch on the shape and depth factors; for Terzaghi, choose the Terzaghi method. You should get the values in the table above.
7. Limits of this example
- It assumes general shear failure and a centric vertical load. Loose or soft soils need the local-shear reduction; eccentric or inclined loads need the effective width B′ and inclination factors.
- Saturated clays need separate short-term (φ = 0, cu) and long-term (c′, φ′) checks. This example is a long-term drained case.
- Bearing capacity is only half of the check. Settlement often governs the allowable pressure; see our foundation settlement sheet.
- The result depends strongly on c′ and φ′. Take them from laboratory tests on representative samples, and take the factor of safety from the code and project requirements.
Our Bearing Capacity Excel sheet does this calculation with live formulas: Meyerhof and Terzaghi side by side, strip, square, circular and rectangular footings, eccentricity, water table, general and local shear, and a printable A4 report. Use the worked example above to test any sheet or program: same inputs, same answer.
Related worked examples
- Foundation Settlement Worked Example — Immediate and Consolidation Settlement
- Lateral Earth Pressure: Rankine Active, At-Rest and Passive — A Worked Example with Water and Surcharge
This article is an educational summary for preliminary checks. Final foundation design needs a site investigation, the criteria of your project and the judgement of the engineer in charge.
Shallow Foundation Bearing Capacity Excel Sheet — Terzaghi and Meyerhof with Water Table — Bilingual
Ultimate and allowable bearing capacity of strip, square, circular and rectangular footings with live formulas: Meyerhof and Terzaghi method…
More guides
Proctor Compaction Test — Optimum Water Content and Maximum Dry Density Worked Example
Foundation Settlement Worked Example — Immediate and Consolidation Settlement
Slope Stability by the Simplified Bishop Method — Worked Example
Atterberg Limits Chart and USCS Classification — Four Worked Examples (CL, CH, ML, SC)
CPT-Based Liquefaction Triggering: The Simplified Method Step by Step, with a Worked Example